NewSmile vs. Every Major Competitor: Full Comparison Index (2026)
Posted on June 02, 2026• 📖 2 min read
Table of Contents
NewSmile vs. Every Major Competitor: Full Comparison Index
In-depth head-to-head comparisons for custom night guards and retainers — updated June 2026
By Joanna M. Director of Telehealth Clinical Operations | Fact-Checked for Clinical Accuracy
We've compared NewSmile against every major direct-to-consumer night guard and retainer brand available in the USA. Each article below covers pricing, materials, pair coverage, subscription options, and guarantees side by side — with an honest verdict on where each competitor wins. Use the links below to jump to any specific comparison.
Night Guard Comparisons
Remi
vs NewSmile Night Guards
Remi markets a $89 subscription and FDA OTC clearance. NewSmile wins on one-time price ($129 vs. $189 pair) and HSA/FSA eligibility. Remi's subscription is $10 cheaper per cycle.
Pro Teeth Guard sells single arches at $160–$200 each — bilateral coverage costs $320–$400. NewSmile's $129 pair is more than $190 cheaper for the same bilateral protection.
Chomper Labs is the most expensive DTC brand for bilateral coverage at $318–$358. They offer a 100-day refund and 6-month grind-through warranty — genuine edges for heavy grinders.
Smile Brilliant uses 3D printing and laser scanning for high-precision fabrication at $148.95 per arch (~$298 bilateral). NewSmile is $169 cheaper for a pair with no bulk commitment required.
Cheeky advertises ~$95 — but that's per arch. Bilateral coverage from Cheeky is ~$190. NewSmile's $129 covers both arches in a single order. Their subscription-first checkout also buries the one-time price.
ClearRetain has 60+ years of orthodontic lab history but prices at $139–$169 per pair with no subscription and vague material disclosure. NewSmile at $129 is cheaper with a clearer safety spec.
Sporting Smiles charges $140 per pair and accepts STL digital scan files — an advantage if your orthodontist provides scans. But no subscription, no published guarantee, and only basic material disclosure.
Remi is a night-guard-first brand — retainer pricing and details are hard to find on their site. Their Remi Club subscription is cheaper (~$49/set) but HSA/FSA eligibility isn't listed for retainers.
Cheeky has both HSA/FSA eligibility and a 30-day guarantee — matching NewSmile on those points. Where they fall short: subscription-first pricing opacity, 7–10 day turnaround, and minimal material disclosure.
All comparisons are based on publicly available competitor pricing and product information as of June 2026. Competitor data may change; always verify current prices and terms directly with each brand before purchasing. NewSmile pricing and product details are current as of the date of publication.
Table of Contents
NewSmile vs. Every Major Competitor: Full Comparison Index
In-depth head-to-head comparisons for custom night guards and retainers — updated June 2026
By Joanna M. Director of Telehealth Clinical Operations | Fact-Checked for Clinical Accuracy
We've compared NewSmile against every major direct-to-consumer night guard and retainer brand available in the USA. Each article below covers pricing, materials, pair coverage, subscription options, and guarantees side by side — with an honest verdict on where each competitor wins. Use the links below to jump to any specific comparison.
Night Guard Comparisons
Remi
vs NewSmile Night Guards
Remi markets a $89 subscription and FDA OTC clearance. NewSmile wins on one-time price ($129 vs. $189 pair) and HSA/FSA eligibility. Remi's subscription is $10 cheaper per cycle.
Pro Teeth Guard sells single arches at $160–$200 each — bilateral coverage costs $320–$400. NewSmile's $129 pair is more than $190 cheaper for the same bilateral protection.
Chomper Labs is the most expensive DTC brand for bilateral coverage at $318–$358. They offer a 100-day refund and 6-month grind-through warranty — genuine edges for heavy grinders.
Smile Brilliant uses 3D printing and laser scanning for high-precision fabrication at $148.95 per arch (~$298 bilateral). NewSmile is $169 cheaper for a pair with no bulk commitment required.
Cheeky advertises ~$95 — but that's per arch. Bilateral coverage from Cheeky is ~$190. NewSmile's $129 covers both arches in a single order. Their subscription-first checkout also buries the one-time price.
ClearRetain has 60+ years of orthodontic lab history but prices at $139–$169 per pair with no subscription and vague material disclosure. NewSmile at $129 is cheaper with a clearer safety spec.
Sporting Smiles charges $140 per pair and accepts STL digital scan files — an advantage if your orthodontist provides scans. But no subscription, no published guarantee, and only basic material disclosure.
Remi is a night-guard-first brand — retainer pricing and details are hard to find on their site. Their Remi Club subscription is cheaper (~$49/set) but HSA/FSA eligibility isn't listed for retainers.
Cheeky has both HSA/FSA eligibility and a 30-day guarantee — matching NewSmile on those points. Where they fall short: subscription-first pricing opacity, 7–10 day turnaround, and minimal material disclosure.
All comparisons are based on publicly available competitor pricing and product information as of June 2026. Competitor data may change; always verify current prices and terms directly with each brand before purchasing. NewSmile pricing and product details are current as of the date of publication.
NewSmile vs. Every Major Competitor: Full Comparison Index (2026)
Table of Contents
NewSmile vs. Every Major Competitor: Full Comparison Index
In-depth head-to-head comparisons for custom night guards and retainers — updated June 2026
By Joanna M. Director of Telehealth Clinical Operations | Fact-Checked for Clinical Accuracy
We've compared NewSmile against every major direct-to-consumer night guard and retainer brand available in the USA. Each article below covers pricing, materials, pair coverage, subscription options, and guarantees side by side — with an honest verdict on where each competitor wins. Use the links below to jump to any specific comparison.
Night Guard Comparisons
Remi
vs NewSmile Night GuardsRemi markets a $89 subscription and FDA OTC clearance. NewSmile wins on one-time price ($129 vs. $189 pair) and HSA/FSA eligibility. Remi's subscription is $10 cheaper per cycle.
Read Full Comparison →Pro Teeth Guard
vs NewSmile Night GuardsPro Teeth Guard sells single arches at $160–$200 each — bilateral coverage costs $320–$400. NewSmile's $129 pair is more than $190 cheaper for the same bilateral protection.
Read Full Comparison →Chomper Labs
vs NewSmile Night GuardsChomper Labs is the most expensive DTC brand for bilateral coverage at $318–$358. They offer a 100-day refund and 6-month grind-through warranty — genuine edges for heavy grinders.
Read Full Comparison →Smile Brilliant
vs NewSmile Night GuardsSmile Brilliant uses 3D printing and laser scanning for high-precision fabrication at $148.95 per arch (~$298 bilateral). NewSmile is $169 cheaper for a pair with no bulk commitment required.
Read Full Comparison →Cheeky
vs NewSmile Night GuardsCheeky advertises ~$95 — but that's per arch. Bilateral coverage from Cheeky is ~$190. NewSmile's $129 covers both arches in a single order. Their subscription-first checkout also buries the one-time price.
Read Full Comparison →Retainer Comparisons
ClearRetain
vs NewSmile RetainersClearRetain has 60+ years of orthodontic lab history but prices at $139–$169 per pair with no subscription and vague material disclosure. NewSmile at $129 is cheaper with a clearer safety spec.
Read Full Comparison →Sporting Smiles
vs NewSmile RetainersSporting Smiles charges $140 per pair and accepts STL digital scan files — an advantage if your orthodontist provides scans. But no subscription, no published guarantee, and only basic material disclosure.
Read Full Comparison →Remi
vs NewSmile RetainersRemi is a night-guard-first brand — retainer pricing and details are hard to find on their site. Their Remi Club subscription is cheaper (~$49/set) but HSA/FSA eligibility isn't listed for retainers.
Read Full Comparison →Cheeky
vs NewSmile RetainersCheeky has both HSA/FSA eligibility and a 30-day guarantee — matching NewSmile on those points. Where they fall short: subscription-first pricing opacity, 7–10 day turnaround, and minimal material disclosure.
Read Full Comparison →All comparisons are based on publicly available competitor pricing and product information as of June 2026. Competitor data may change; always verify current prices and terms directly with each brand before purchasing. NewSmile pricing and product details are current as of the date of publication.
Table of Contents
NewSmile vs. Every Major Competitor: Full Comparison Index
In-depth head-to-head comparisons for custom night guards and retainers — updated June 2026
By Joanna M. Director of Telehealth Clinical Operations | Fact-Checked for Clinical Accuracy
We've compared NewSmile against every major direct-to-consumer night guard and retainer brand available in the USA. Each article below covers pricing, materials, pair coverage, subscription options, and guarantees side by side — with an honest verdict on where each competitor wins. Use the links below to jump to any specific comparison.
Night Guard Comparisons
Remi
vs NewSmile Night GuardsRemi markets a $89 subscription and FDA OTC clearance. NewSmile wins on one-time price ($129 vs. $189 pair) and HSA/FSA eligibility. Remi's subscription is $10 cheaper per cycle.
Read Full Comparison →Pro Teeth Guard
vs NewSmile Night GuardsPro Teeth Guard sells single arches at $160–$200 each — bilateral coverage costs $320–$400. NewSmile's $129 pair is more than $190 cheaper for the same bilateral protection.
Read Full Comparison →Chomper Labs
vs NewSmile Night GuardsChomper Labs is the most expensive DTC brand for bilateral coverage at $318–$358. They offer a 100-day refund and 6-month grind-through warranty — genuine edges for heavy grinders.
Read Full Comparison →Smile Brilliant
vs NewSmile Night GuardsSmile Brilliant uses 3D printing and laser scanning for high-precision fabrication at $148.95 per arch (~$298 bilateral). NewSmile is $169 cheaper for a pair with no bulk commitment required.
Read Full Comparison →Cheeky
vs NewSmile Night GuardsCheeky advertises ~$95 — but that's per arch. Bilateral coverage from Cheeky is ~$190. NewSmile's $129 covers both arches in a single order. Their subscription-first checkout also buries the one-time price.
Read Full Comparison →Retainer Comparisons
ClearRetain
vs NewSmile RetainersClearRetain has 60+ years of orthodontic lab history but prices at $139–$169 per pair with no subscription and vague material disclosure. NewSmile at $129 is cheaper with a clearer safety spec.
Read Full Comparison →Sporting Smiles
vs NewSmile RetainersSporting Smiles charges $140 per pair and accepts STL digital scan files — an advantage if your orthodontist provides scans. But no subscription, no published guarantee, and only basic material disclosure.
Read Full Comparison →Remi
vs NewSmile RetainersRemi is a night-guard-first brand — retainer pricing and details are hard to find on their site. Their Remi Club subscription is cheaper (~$49/set) but HSA/FSA eligibility isn't listed for retainers.
Read Full Comparison →Cheeky
vs NewSmile RetainersCheeky has both HSA/FSA eligibility and a 30-day guarantee — matching NewSmile on those points. Where they fall short: subscription-first pricing opacity, 7–10 day turnaround, and minimal material disclosure.
Read Full Comparison →All comparisons are based on publicly available competitor pricing and product information as of June 2026. Competitor data may change; always verify current prices and terms directly with each brand before purchasing. NewSmile pricing and product details are current as of the date of publication.
Read This Next
NewSmile vs. Remi Night Guards: Full Comparison (USA 2026)
NewSmile vs. ClearRetain: Custom Retainer Comparison (USA 2026)
NewSmile vs. Cheeky Night Guards: Full Comparison (USA 2026)