Custom vs Store-Bought Night Guards: Cost & Effectiveness
Posted on October 22, 2025• 📖 3 min read
Table of Contents
When you wake up with a sore jaw, morning headaches, or tooth wear, you may be facing the all-too-common issue of nighttime teeth grinding (bruxism). The question arises: Are custom night guards better than store-bought?
In this lifestyle-style blog post, we’ll walk through four main pillars — Cost, Fit & Comfort, Durability & Effectiveness, and Lifestyle & Convenience — to help you decide which option truly fits your lifestyle and budget.
We’ll also mention how NewSmile offers a custom-fit alternative that bridges dentist-level quality with at-home convenience.
Cost – What You Pay Up-Front and Over Time
Store-Bought / Over-The-Counter (OTC): These guards are generally priced between $10 and $100 and can be found at most drugstores. They offer a convenient, low-cost solution, but may need replacing every few months.
Custom Night Guards: Professionally crafted guards typically range from $300 to $1,000+, depending on the provider. Online options like NewSmile offer a custom-fit guard for around $149–$179, giving you dentist-level comfort and protection at a fraction of the price.
“Choosing the cheapest guard up-front may cost more in replacements in the long run.”
“Choosing the cheapest guard up-front may cost more in replacements in the long run.”
Fit & Comfort – Does It Actually Feel Good (and Stay On)?
Fit Differences:
Custom guards are made from precise molds of your teeth — either via dentist or home-impression kit (like NewSmile’s).
Store-bought guards rely on “one-size-fits-all” or “boil-and-bite,” often leading to uneven pressure and poor retention.
Comfort & Bulk:
Ill-fitting OTC guards can irritate gums or fall out at night.
Custom guards feel thinner, more natural, and easier to sleep with.
“A night guard that doesn’t feel good is one you won’t wear — and one you won’t protect your teeth with.”
Durability & Effectiveness – Protection That Lasts
✓Custom guards are proven to offer superior protection against enamel wear, fractures, and TMJ pain.
✓OTC guards often compress unevenly or lose shape quickly, reducing their ability to prevent damage.
✓Custom guards: typically last 2–5 years.
✓Store-bought: 3–12 months before cracking or warping.
“The guard that lasts longer and actually protects may cost more today — but could save your teeth (and wallet) later.”
FAQs
1
Are custom night guards always better than store-bought?
Usually yes, especially for moderate-to-severe grinding. OTC options are best for short-term or light grinding.
2
How much does a custom night guard cost?
Anywhere from $150–$1,000 depending on provider. Online brands like NewSmile make them far more affordable.
3
How long does a night guard last?
Custom guards typically last 2–5 years; OTC ones, 3–12 months.
4
Can a poorly fitting guard cause harm?
Yes. Ill-fitting guards can cause gum irritation, tooth shifting, or worsen jaw pain.
5
How do I decide between OTC and custom?
Consider your grinding severity, budget, comfort needs, and long-term dental goals.
When you wake up with a sore jaw, morning headaches, or tooth wear, you may be facing the all-too-common issue of nighttime teeth grinding (bruxism). The question arises: Are custom night guards better than store-bought?
In this lifestyle-style blog post, we’ll walk through four main pillars — Cost, Fit & Comfort, Durability & Effectiveness, and Lifestyle & Convenience — to help you decide which option truly fits your lifestyle and budget.
We’ll also mention how NewSmile offers a custom-fit alternative that bridges dentist-level quality with at-home convenience.
Cost – What You Pay Up-Front and Over Time
Store-Bought / Over-The-Counter (OTC): These guards are generally priced between $10 and $100 and can be found at most drugstores. They offer a convenient, low-cost solution, but may need replacing every few months.
Custom Night Guards: Professionally crafted guards typically range from $300 to $1,000+, depending on the provider. Online options like NewSmile offer a custom-fit guard for around $149–$179, giving you dentist-level comfort and protection at a fraction of the price.
“Choosing the cheapest guard up-front may cost more in replacements in the long run.”
“Choosing the cheapest guard up-front may cost more in replacements in the long run.”
Fit & Comfort – Does It Actually Feel Good (and Stay On)?
Fit Differences:
Custom guards are made from precise molds of your teeth — either via dentist or home-impression kit (like NewSmile’s).
Store-bought guards rely on “one-size-fits-all” or “boil-and-bite,” often leading to uneven pressure and poor retention.
Comfort & Bulk:
Ill-fitting OTC guards can irritate gums or fall out at night.
Custom guards feel thinner, more natural, and easier to sleep with.
“A night guard that doesn’t feel good is one you won’t wear — and one you won’t protect your teeth with.”
Durability & Effectiveness – Protection That Lasts
✓Custom guards are proven to offer superior protection against enamel wear, fractures, and TMJ pain.
✓OTC guards often compress unevenly or lose shape quickly, reducing their ability to prevent damage.
✓Custom guards: typically last 2–5 years.
✓Store-bought: 3–12 months before cracking or warping.
“The guard that lasts longer and actually protects may cost more today — but could save your teeth (and wallet) later.”
FAQs
1
Are custom night guards always better than store-bought?
Usually yes, especially for moderate-to-severe grinding. OTC options are best for short-term or light grinding.
2
How much does a custom night guard cost?
Anywhere from $150–$1,000 depending on provider. Online brands like NewSmile make them far more affordable.
3
How long does a night guard last?
Custom guards typically last 2–5 years; OTC ones, 3–12 months.
4
Can a poorly fitting guard cause harm?
Yes. Ill-fitting guards can cause gum irritation, tooth shifting, or worsen jaw pain.
5
How do I decide between OTC and custom?
Consider your grinding severity, budget, comfort needs, and long-term dental goals.
Custom vs Store-Bought Night Guards: Cost & Effectiveness
Table of Contents
When you wake up with a sore jaw, morning headaches, or tooth wear, you may be facing the all-too-common issue of nighttime teeth grinding (bruxism). The question arises: Are custom night guards better than store-bought?
In this lifestyle-style blog post, we’ll walk through four main pillars — Cost, Fit & Comfort, Durability & Effectiveness, and Lifestyle & Convenience — to help you decide which option truly fits your lifestyle and budget.
We’ll also mention how NewSmile offers a custom-fit alternative that bridges dentist-level quality with at-home convenience.
Cost – What You Pay Up-Front and Over Time
Store-Bought / Over-The-Counter (OTC): These guards are generally priced between $10 and $100 and can be found at most drugstores. They offer a convenient, low-cost solution, but may need replacing every few months.
Custom Night Guards: Professionally crafted guards typically range from $300 to $1,000+, depending on the provider. Online options like NewSmile offer a custom-fit guard for around $149–$179, giving you dentist-level comfort and protection at a fraction of the price.
Fit & Comfort – Does It Actually Feel Good (and Stay On)?
Fit Differences:
Custom guards are made from precise molds of your teeth — either via dentist or home-impression kit (like NewSmile’s).
Store-bought guards rely on “one-size-fits-all” or “boil-and-bite,” often leading to uneven pressure and poor retention.
Comfort & Bulk:
Ill-fitting OTC guards can irritate gums or fall out at night.
Custom guards feel thinner, more natural, and easier to sleep with.
Durability & Effectiveness – Protection That Lasts
FAQs
Are custom night guards always better than store-bought?
Usually yes, especially for moderate-to-severe grinding. OTC options are best for short-term or light grinding.
How much does a custom night guard cost?
Anywhere from $150–$1,000 depending on provider. Online brands like NewSmile make them far more affordable.
How long does a night guard last?
Custom guards typically last 2–5 years; OTC ones, 3–12 months.
Can a poorly fitting guard cause harm?
Yes. Ill-fitting guards can cause gum irritation, tooth shifting, or worsen jaw pain.
How do I decide between OTC and custom?
Consider your grinding severity, budget, comfort needs, and long-term dental goals.
Citations
Cleveland Clinic – Mouthguards Overview
Colgate – Over-the-Counter vs Custom Night Guards
ProTeethGuard – Dentist Night Guard vs OTC
SmilePath NZ – Custom vs OTC Mouth Guards
NewSmile Blog – Myths vs Facts About Clear Night Guards
NewSmile – Night Guard Product Page
Everyday Health – Best Affordable Invisible Braces (NewSmile review)
Inglewood Family Dental – Custom vs OTC Night Guards
Real Simple – How to Choose a Mouth Guard for Grinding Teeth
Denver Wynkoop Dentist – Difference Between Store-Bought and Dentist-Made Night Guards
Table of Contents
When you wake up with a sore jaw, morning headaches, or tooth wear, you may be facing the all-too-common issue of nighttime teeth grinding (bruxism). The question arises: Are custom night guards better than store-bought?
In this lifestyle-style blog post, we’ll walk through four main pillars — Cost, Fit & Comfort, Durability & Effectiveness, and Lifestyle & Convenience — to help you decide which option truly fits your lifestyle and budget.
We’ll also mention how NewSmile offers a custom-fit alternative that bridges dentist-level quality with at-home convenience.
Cost – What You Pay Up-Front and Over Time
Store-Bought / Over-The-Counter (OTC): These guards are generally priced between $10 and $100 and can be found at most drugstores. They offer a convenient, low-cost solution, but may need replacing every few months.
Custom Night Guards: Professionally crafted guards typically range from $300 to $1,000+, depending on the provider. Online options like NewSmile offer a custom-fit guard for around $149–$179, giving you dentist-level comfort and protection at a fraction of the price.
Fit & Comfort – Does It Actually Feel Good (and Stay On)?
Fit Differences:
Custom guards are made from precise molds of your teeth — either via dentist or home-impression kit (like NewSmile’s).
Store-bought guards rely on “one-size-fits-all” or “boil-and-bite,” often leading to uneven pressure and poor retention.
Comfort & Bulk:
Ill-fitting OTC guards can irritate gums or fall out at night.
Custom guards feel thinner, more natural, and easier to sleep with.
Durability & Effectiveness – Protection That Lasts
FAQs
Are custom night guards always better than store-bought?
Usually yes, especially for moderate-to-severe grinding. OTC options are best for short-term or light grinding.
How much does a custom night guard cost?
Anywhere from $150–$1,000 depending on provider. Online brands like NewSmile make them far more affordable.
How long does a night guard last?
Custom guards typically last 2–5 years; OTC ones, 3–12 months.
Can a poorly fitting guard cause harm?
Yes. Ill-fitting guards can cause gum irritation, tooth shifting, or worsen jaw pain.
How do I decide between OTC and custom?
Consider your grinding severity, budget, comfort needs, and long-term dental goals.
Citations
Cleveland Clinic – Mouthguards Overview
Colgate – Over-the-Counter vs Custom Night Guards
ProTeethGuard – Dentist Night Guard vs OTC
SmilePath NZ – Custom vs OTC Mouth Guards
NewSmile Blog – Myths vs Facts About Clear Night Guards
NewSmile – Night Guard Product Page
Everyday Health – Best Affordable Invisible Braces (NewSmile review)
Inglewood Family Dental – Custom vs OTC Night Guards
Real Simple – How to Choose a Mouth Guard for Grinding Teeth
Denver Wynkoop Dentist – Difference Between Store-Bought and Dentist-Made Night Guards
Read This Next
How the Petal Ultrasonic Cleaner Transforms Your Cleaning Routine
Nightguards 101: Everything You Need to Know
The Best Nightguards for Teeth Grinding: A Buyer’s Guide